
What's the origin of the word Education? What's the POINT of education? Is it to 'put stuff in' or to 'get stuff out'? Presumably it's both...
In this paper by Randall V Bass and J W Good, they write;
Craft (1984) noted that there are two different Latin roots of the English word "education." They are "educare," which means to train or to mold, and "educere," meaning to lead out. While the two meanings are quite different, they are both represented in the word "education." Thus, there is an etymological basis for many of the vociferous debates about education today. The opposing sides often use the same word to denote two very different concepts. One side uses education to mean the preservation and passing down of knowledge and the shaping of youths in the image of their parents. The other side sees education as preparing a new generation for the changes that are to come--readying them to create solutions to problems yet unknown. One calls for rote memorization and becoming good workers. The other requires questioning, thinking, and creating. To further complicate matters, some groups expect schooling to fulfill both functions, but allow only those activities promoting educare to be used. Balance in educational aims is a valid focus for educators. This author contends that, in order to achieve balance, educators must start by changing the organizational structure or the ways in which decisions are made. Utilizing stakeholder perceptions in determining aims, establishing a shared vision of education, and facilitating a change in educators' roles are initial steps. To accomplish a change in thinking, educators must examine their own personal mastery and mental models of education
Food for thought in advance of In The Wild!
I vote for both
"To accomplish a change in thinking, educators must examine their own personal mastery and mental models of education" - except these may be untypical - after all, educators generally are those who found school (and university) a successful experience. A really important issue is understanding the diversity of ways of attaining mastery and taking mental models of education and making them expilicit and outward in the hope that we can develop a comprehensive vision.